Roofing Insights / Comparing estimates
Why am I getting different quotes?
A homeowner’s guide to roof replacement prices on Whidbey Island and in Anacortes.
Two roofers can measure the same house and give you different prices because they are buying different materials, allowing for different work, or running different kinds of companies. Financing can add another difference. When I look at two proposals, I start with three numbers: the measured roof area, the price for the same work if you pay without contractor financing, and the amount you would pay over the life of any loan.
What does an asphalt shingle roof start at locally?
At Wind Proof Roofing, I use $500–$650 per roofing square as a starting point for a straightforward asphalt shingle replacement with one existing layer. That works out to $5.00–$6.50 per square foot of roof surface. This is my November 2026 budgeting guidance for Whidbey Island and Anacortes. Other contractors set their own prices.
| Measured roof area | Roofing squares | Starting range |
|---|---|---|
| 2,000 sq. ft. | 20 | $10,000–$13,000 |
| 2,500 sq. ft. | 25 | $12,500–$16,250 |
| 3,000 sq. ft. | 30 | $15,000–$19,500 |
These examples multiply measured area by the base rate. They show no separate amount for sales tax, damaged decking, difficult access or optional upgrades. Ask each roofer to identify tear-off, disposal, installation, materials, and sales tax in the written price. Standing seam metal and low-slope membrane roofs require their own estimates.
What is a roofing square?
One roofing square covers 100 square feet of actual roof surface. A 10-foot by 10-foot section measured along the slope is one square. Add the area of all roof planes, including overhangs, and divide by 100. Your home’s listed floor area measures something different. A second story adds living space under the same roof, while pitch, garages and overhangs change how much roof there is to cover. GAF’s roofing-square guide.
The order quantity can also differ from the measured area. If a 25-square roof needs a 10% allowance for cuts in an example, the contractor would allow 27.5 squares before rounding to bundles. Valleys and dormers can change that allowance. Ask, “Is the square count on this bid the area of my roof or the amount of material you plan to order?”
How much of the difference is in the work itself?
Start with the exact shingle line, the number of old layers coming off, and the labor to reach and work on the roof. Then look at the details around a chimney, a skylight or a wall. One roofer may have included new metal flashing where another intends to reuse the existing pieces. On a Whidbey roof exposed to wind-driven rain, I want you to know which detail I’m proposing and why.
Here’s how the math can fool you. Suppose two bids both price the basic work at $15,000. Bid A includes a $900 allowance for 10 sheets of decking at $90 each, bringing its total to $15,900. Bid B lists $15,000 and prices damaged decking separately at the same $90 per sheet. If 10 sheets need replacing, the totals match before tax. If only two do, ask whether A credits the unused $720, and how B documents and gets approval for the extra $180. The written allowance terms decide what you pay. Compare roofing scopes line by line.
Do local and regional roofers price jobs differently?
At Wind Proof Roofing, I handle our estimates myself. We keep our overhead lean, and there’s no separate salesperson’s commission on the jobs I sell. We still have to cover the cost of estimating, insurance, vehicles, equipment and showing up for service after the job. When you call me about a line on our estimate, you can speak with the person who put it there.
Some local roofers work the same way. Others employ estimators or pay a sales commission. A contractor that started in one town and expanded across a region may support several offices, a sales team, project managers and a service department. Those costs can affect its bid. Buying larger quantities or sharing crews and equipment can also lower costs. A company’s size alone won’t tell you its price or the quality of its work. Ask who will supervise your installation and who will handle a callback.
How has private equity changed the roofing market?
Private equity firms invest in businesses and sometimes combine several contractors under one parent company. A familiar local name can stay on the truck while the company gains shared purchasing, marketing, or administrative support. KPMG counted 10 selected roofing-contractor transactions in 2020 and 56 in 2025. That national count includes both financial and corporate buyers. It shows the growth in deals KPMG tracked. KPMG roofing contracting report.
There’s a recent example in North Puget Sound. In November 2026, Infinity Home Services announced a partnership with S&S Roofing and described the technology and support the local team would share. In 2023, LightBay Capital and Freeman Spogli announced that they and management had acquired Infinity. These announcements tell us about ownership and resources. They disclose no homeowner prices. Local partnership announcement · Infinity ownership announcement.
Ownership has changed at the supply counter, too. SRS Distribution, a supplier serving professional roofers, was backed by Leonard Green & Partners and Berkshire Partners. Home Depot bought SRS in June 2024 for about $18.25 billion. That was a retailer buying a distributor previously backed by private equity. The deal tells you who owns the supplier. To understand your materials price, compare the shingle, underlayment, flashing, delivery and quantities in the actual proposals. SRS’s former investors · Home Depot’s completed acquisition.
Does a low-interest roof loan have a hidden dealer fee?
Some lenders charge the roofing company a dealer fee, also called a merchant or program fee, to offer a financing plan. The fee pays for access to that loan program or its promotional terms. A contractor’s license is a separate matter. A low advertised rate alone won’t tell you whether there is a fee, what it is, or whether the homeowner’s price changes.
For a roofing-specific example, Wisetack lists a 3.9% merchant fee on standard transactions and 6.9% for a 12-month 0% plan. On $15,000 financed, those are costs to the contractor of $585 or $1,035. Wisetack prohibits adding its fee as a surcharge to the customer’s invoice. These are one provider’s published figures, not an offer from Wind Proof. Wisetack’s roofing terms · Merchant fee policy.
If you’ve heard “30% goes to the lender,” check what the figure describes. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau documented hidden fees commonly ranging from 10% to 30% of the cash price in solar financing. Its example turned a $30,000 solar installation into a $39,000 loan before interest. That research covers solar loans. It does not establish a standard 30% fee for a roof replacement. CFPB solar financing report.
A home equity line of credit (HELOC) is another way to pay. Your home secures it, the rate is usually variable, and closing or annual fees may apply. If comparing it with contractor-arranged financing, use the same borrowed amount and intended payoff period. CFPB’s HELOC explanation · Potential HELOC fees.
What should I ask before choosing a quote?
- “What is your cash price for this exact scope, including tax?” Compare the same roof area, materials, labor, disposal and warranty. Ask each roofer to mark exclusions and allowances.
- “Does this financing plan charge your company a dealer fee? Does choosing it change my price?” Ask for the cash proposal and the written loan offer side by side.
- “With the same down payment, how much will I actually pay?” Compare the amount financed, APR, term, monthly payment and total of payments. Add the down payment and any separately paid upfront fees once. For a promotion, ask what happens to interest if a balance remains at the deadline.
- “Who approves extra work, and who stands behind the roof?” Ask for unit prices, the change-order process, the installing company’s legal name and the workmanship warranty contact. Washington L&I also recommends getting three written bids. Washington’s homeowner guide.
